Tidy Ledger Co.

Excel vs Google Sheets for Budgeting: Which Should You Use in 2027?

By Tidy Ledger Co. · · 3 min read

Short answer

Google Sheets is the better choice for most people who want a free budget they can share with a partner and open on any device. Microsoft Excel is better if you already pay for Microsoft 365, want to work offline, or need heavier analysis and richer charts. A well-built .xlsx budget template without macros works in both, so you can start in one and switch later.

Key takeaways

  • Google Sheets: free, real-time sharing, works in any browser.
  • Excel: powerful, works offline, richer formatting and charts.
  • Both have mobile apps that are fine for quick logging; setup is easier on a computer.
  • Avoid macros (VBA) if you want a template to work in both.

Both Microsoft Excel and Google Sheets can run a household budget perfectly well. The right choice depends less on features and more on how you live: whether you share money with someone, which devices you use, and whether you already pay for Microsoft 365.

The short answer

  • Choose Google Sheets if you want a free tool, need to share the budget with a partner, or switch between devices a lot.
  • Choose Excel if you already have Microsoft 365, prefer working offline, or like deeper analysis and polished charts.

Side-by-side comparison

Google SheetsMicrosoft Excel
CostFree with a Google accountPaid (Microsoft 365 or one-off licence); Excel for the web is free with a Microsoft account, with fewer features
SharingExcellent real-time collaborationGood via OneDrive/SharePoint and Microsoft 365
OfflinePossible with offline mode set up in ChromeFull offline desktop app
Mobile appYes (iOS and Android)Yes (iOS and Android)
FormulasCovers everything a budget needsMost extensive function library
Charts & formattingGoodRicher options
MacrosApps Script (not VBA)VBA macros
Large filesCan slow down with very large sheetsHandles large workbooks well

Cost

Google Sheets costs nothing. Excel desktop requires a Microsoft 365 subscription or a one-off licence, although many people already have it through work, school or a family plan. Excel for the web is free with a Microsoft account and handles most budgets, though some features are reduced.

Sharing with a partner

This is where Google Sheets shines. Both partners can edit the same file at the same time from their phones, and changes appear instantly. Excel supports co-authoring too, through OneDrive, and it works well inside the Microsoft ecosystem. If one of you uses an iPhone and the other an Android phone, either tool works.

Privacy and control

Both are cloud services when you use them online. Google Sheets files live in your Google Drive; Excel files can stay purely on your computer if you prefer. If you want your budget to never touch the cloud, Excel desktop with a local file is the simplest route. Whichever you choose, use a strong password and two-factor authentication on the account — your budget reveals a lot about your life.

Mobile logging

Both mobile apps are fine for quick entries — date, amount, category — and for glancing at a dashboard. Setup, editing categories and reviewing charts is far more comfortable on a computer. Tip: add a home-screen shortcut directly to your budget file so logging is one tap away.

Formulas and features a budget needs

A good household budget relies on a handful of functions that both tools support: SUMIFS for totals by category and month, IF/IFERROR for status messages, date functions such as EOMONTH for month ranges, data validation drop-downs, and conditional formatting for colour cues. Excel adds powerful extras (Power Query, PivotTables with more options, more chart types), but most people never need them for a personal budget.

Moving an Excel budget into Google Sheets

  1. Open Google Drive and click New › File upload, then choose the .xlsx file.
  2. Double-click the uploaded file — it opens in Google Sheets.
  3. Choose File › Save as Google Sheets. This creates a native copy, which is faster and fully editable.
  4. Check that drop-downs, colours and charts look right, then start using the new copy.

Templates without macros convert cleanly; anything that depends on VBA won’t run in Google Sheets.

What about Apple Numbers?

Numbers is free on Apple devices and opens many .xlsx files, but complex formulas, data validation and conditional formatting don’t always survive the conversion. For a feature-rich template, stick with Excel or Google Sheets — both run in a browser on a Mac.

Our recommendation

Start where you already are. If you live in Google’s world, use Sheets. If you already pay for Microsoft 365, use Excel. And choose a template that works in both — no macros, no add-ons — so you are never locked in.

Product names are trademarks of their respective owners. This site is not affiliated with Microsoft, Google or Apple.

Frequently asked questions

Is Google Sheets good enough for budgeting?

Yes. Google Sheets handles everything a household budget needs — formulas, conditional formatting, charts, data validation and sharing — for free.

Can I open an Excel budget in Google Sheets?

Yes. Upload the .xlsx file to Google Drive, open it with Google Sheets, then choose File > Save as Google Sheets for the best experience. Macros (VBA) will not run, so choose templates that don't rely on them.

Does Excel work on a Mac?

Yes. Microsoft Excel is available for macOS as part of Microsoft 365 or as a standalone purchase, and Excel for the web runs in any browser.

Can I use Apple Numbers instead?

Numbers can open many .xlsx files, but complex formulas, data validation and conditional formatting may not convert correctly. For advanced templates, Excel or Google Sheets is more reliable.